NaliCity
HomeMapsServersForumsMy NaliSubmitChatLinks
Sun, December 9, 2018
Latest Additions
Latest Reviews
Latest Comments
UT Color UT UT2k3 color UT2k3
U2 UT2k4

NaliCity Mothership
65.39.251.19:7777

Search

-Game-

-Map-



Advanced Search

Menu



more...
more...
more...

Welcome to Nali City
Register | Login


VCTF-Illusion 
Map Info


 
File Namevctf-illusion.zip
AuthorKantham
GametypeUT2k4 Vehicle CTF
Date Added01-15-2005
File Version1.00
File Size5.48 mb
Player Count8-12
Map DescriptionA good map online
(even if the bots 'play' )
Review Rating6
User Rating7
Overall Rating7.0



 
Review


ReviewerArcadiaVincennesAwe Score: 2.0/3
Date05-20-2005Build Score: 2.5/3
Review SchemaCast Score: 1.5/3
User Point: +1
Overall Score: 7.0/10

VCTF-Illusion (UT2004)

A floating vctf map with three paths, relatively narrow roads, and interesting gameplay. Is it a 'floater' or does it make the cut?

AWE: 2.0

The textures are pretty well aligned throughout the map. The textures on the BSP all share the same color pallette of various browns. The variation is mostly left to the meshes to take care of. There are some shiny cube-mapped textures scattered around the map that donít really make sense with the Ďjunkyardí theme the map tends towards. Many of the meshes are large concrete forms with smaller rusty boxes, scrap metal, and such that make the overall placement seem like a scrap metal yard. The cubemapped textures used for road joints go against the rusty theme by being so chrome-like with nary a scratch on them. Theyíre well made but probably should not have been used in order to support the theme better.
The lighting is both good and bad. Thereís a bit of nice shadow work but all the surfaces exposed to the sky Ė which is a large portion of the map Ė share the same brightness from the sun. Granted the map is set in a city with an open cloudless sky, I personally often find noon, or near-noon settings lacking in terms ambience potential. The Ďundergroundí areas are, in comparison, almost too dark. The shadows weigh far more heavily here and thereís minimal light to brighten it up. Itís a nice contrast to be sure, however, a bit less depth I believe would have worked better.
The architecture is fairly nice. The main structures aside from the two flag areas feel simply like large blocks of BSP with some holes cut out of them. The meshes are really what help bring the architecture together to give it a feel of an industrial scrapyard. The overall effect is pretty nice but some more buts into the BSP would have helped ground the theme in the architecture better.
Finally, I personally believe everything in the air should have some sort of support. I understand the challenge in terms of supporting the entire map, but I am displeased by the notion that the two flag base areas are completely unsupported and connected to the rest of the map only by the paths that lead you to them.
The skybox deserves a little bit of special attention. The skybox is a simple cube with textures appropriate to the 6 faces of the cube. Itís a cityscape with an open sky, tall skyscrapers, and a bottom. Compared to the other 5 textures used, the bottom looks and feels awkward. Iím not quite sure what itís intended to represent in terms of a city unless itís supposed to be sunlit roads broken up by shadows cast from the buildings. If this is the case, it doesnít seem like the shadows are coming from the buildings surrounding the floor. If this is not the case, then I donít know what itís meant to represent. Other than this curiousity, when playing the map itís abundantly clear that the skybox is a cube which detracts from the suspension of reality that itís supposed to convey. I think itís a good effort, but it needs a whole lot more to bring the Ďillusioní of a city home.
Overall, the textureing is pretty good, although the color palette could be a little more varied. The lighting is nicely done but with a bit too much contrast between light and dark. Finally the architecture also is nice but some more detail work I think would have brought out the polish more. In general I think itís Ďniceí and Ďgoodí but itís a few steps short of being great.

BUILD: 2.5

The author is obviously competent working with the editor. No HOMs, no awkward joints between BSP, nor between BSP and meshes, thereís nothing that really looks intrinsicly badly done or Ďbrokení. As is the case with most VCTF maps the bots behave a bit wonky. I donít really play VCTF too much but Iím lead to understand that pathing VCTF maps is tricky yet possible. Perhaps the author should research VCTF pathing a little more extensively when working on his next oeuvre. Other than the pathing, I found the ambient sounds lacking. Thereís some general sound but more locational and triggerd sounds would have helped polish up the ambience even more. Clanks and rattles would be a welcome addition to the map.

CAST: 1.5

The first problem the map has is the wonky bots as mentioned earlier. If left to themselves, they would do an adequate job. However, when playing with/against them, they always seemed a step behind and were easily distracted by combat opportunities. Again, I would recommend more VCTF pathing research.
The next problem is the setting itself. A junkyard suspended in the air by who knows what, you are already dealing with the classic avoiding the edge to survive gameplay ploy which I always feel is fairly cheap and is difficult to really do right. Second, I found that the paths to use in the center areas were just barely wide enough. Except for chokepoints, my opinion is that there should always be room to pass other vehicles with space to spare. I feel that the author carefully calculated this distance and made the main paths exactly that wide. I would have preferred a little more Ďwiggle roomí in the paths. As for the flag bases, Iím not sure if the paths are the same width as in the center but they Ďfeltí smaller and tighter which does add a challenge to capping the flag, but on the other hand thereís almost no structure where defenders can stand thatís not in the road Ė which makes defending very risky. And this also forces gameplay to the center areas where thereís (slightly) more room to maneuver.
Also, the non-central, non-air path is almost a bit too circuitous to be worth trying although the lower area does have a few nice pickups. But itís quite long and the flag capper will have quite the challege making it all the from one end to another without a lot of help from their teammates.
One nice thing the author did was create the spawn areas well away from the flag area. Itís a nice touch and based on the layout it still provides relatively rapid defense times because you can drop down on them as they try to get away. And itís always a good idea not to spawn on top of the flag anyways. Not that thereís room to do that in this map, anyway.
As for FPS, youíll go from above retail to below throughout the map. When itís low, itís not enough to really have that large an impact on gameplay except on very low-end systems so not too bad overall.
In general the gameplay is a bit of a mixed bag. With the narrow driving areas, limiting alternate route, and threat of death from falling, the gameplay leaves a bit to be desired. However, the spawn area positioning and exposure to air vehicles, the gameplay could potentially be fairly good. Too bad the bots donít think the same thing.

Does VCTF give the illusion of a pretty map with good gameplay but doesnít meet up with itís promise? Not quite, but the map seems to be lacking a little bit of polish overall. The visual pallete is a little bland in terms of color and lighting and the skybox is mostly just confusing. The gameplay also has its plusses and minuses but those players who enjoy the threat of falling should enjoy the map overall. For pure VCTF players, this map might be a bit disappointing but itís worth a try.




 
Map Comments


n00bkillin
01-16-2005 03:50 AM EST
 
The download link doesn't work. Does it acually have bot support? The comment you gave could've implied it.

G.Lecter
01-16-2005 07:40 AM EST
 
I won't rate it because I had not really fun with bots. I will come back & change the comment if I play it online one of these days...
= Visuals:
- The visuals are well done. The mirrors are a bit confusing. The skybox is a little strange and I think it does not fit with the map, but at least is a new custom skybox...
- The lighting is well done, but quite simple. Something darker with more dynamic lights would habe been better...
= Layout & Placement:
- The layout works well for VCTF. There are 2 different paths, but only one way to enter the base. A tank camper could stay there and kill everyoune. Each team has 2 Raptors that could help to avoid camping...
- I predict the straight path will be dominated by Tanks & Paladins when playing online.
- Items & Vehicles are well placed overall. I only saw 4 useless healths next to the playerstart ponts...
- I did not like the Teleporter/Jumpad system. It gives a bad advantage to pedestrians...
= Bot support:
- Bots can run through the map. Unfortunately, they don't play really well, but the author did all possible to make a good botpath. (The AI for VCTF is terrible & the best way to play this is online).
= Why it has no level preview???
It's a good map. I saw this author maps for VCTF better than for other styles, and I think he should keep mapping for this gamtype... ;)

IN_tr_der5
01-27-2005 07:06 AM EST
Rating: 4 
was ok...i like some of ya maps but seem to have to re-path the bots a bit....

Manticore
03-11-2005 02:40 AM EST
Rating: 7 
AT least this map has multiple gameplay paths which many VCTF maps lack. Interesting theme and visuals. Worth a look...

Monday
04-28-2005 05:01 AM EDT
 


Map Description A good map online
(even if the bots 'play' )



Nice look though.

Freedomshaoray
05-23-2005 07:08 PM EDT
 
wow city theme...got to try it ;)

Kantham
05-24-2005 12:11 PM EDT
 
more to come ;)


But that time with no F***** bot suport.



About Nali City | Staff | Contact Us | Report an Error | Privacy Policy
Become a Reviewer | Review Schema | Stats

Copyright © 1998-2018 BeyondUnreal, Inc.


PHP/Coding by MassChAoS, Iridium, Varpu, and Yoda.

Website design by Olento. Modified by MassChAoS.

NC3 concepts and ideas by the NC3 community,
MassChAoS, Varpu, Yoda, Bangout, and Luquado.

NaliCity founded by QAPete.