Homeslice
07-10-2003 11:58 PM MDT | Rating: 0 | |
This might sound harsh, but this totally does NOT deserve a 10. I mean....a 10?? What's up with that? My maps, I hate to brag, are better than this, and these are the Homeslice maps, the ones that suck!! They're better than this!!
EDIT: We who give 0 know NOTHING about maps? That should be the other way around. See, you don't know what a good map is. Try something from guys like DavidM or Plutonic or Tonnberry or even the new guy, L.J. Paranoid, if you wanna see something GOOD!
|
Lophead
12-11-2002 07:21 PM MST | Rating: 3 | |
dude...
|
Mxtrmntr
12-14-2002 12:22 PM MST | Rating: 2 | |
heh, this had to be resurrected one day.
(changed my score a bit down btw after reconsidering and comparing it to other maps of the same rating btw o_O )
|
Luquado
12-12-2002 03:07 AM MST | Rating: 1 | |
And the joke lives on!
|
Tonnberry
12-12-2002 07:49 AM MST | Rating: 0 | |
alltime classic =)
|
Koveras
12-12-2002 12:03 PM MST | Rating: 10 | |
hopefully we'll see a UT2003 version of this map and we'll give it a 10 too!
|
Vertigo
12-12-2002 12:21 PM MST | Rating: 1 | |
Ok, lighting is good, but only in a few places. Have you seen that hallway?? Or is too bright or its unlit but its totally a ****!!!!!
|
DavidM
12-13-2002 11:50 AM MST | Rating: 0 | |
Its somewhere between tonnberry's and luquados score....but I guess tonnberry is closer,so...
|
SkaarjMaster
12-13-2002 12:29 PM MST | Rating: 4 | |
This map has really gotten a bad rap in the past, but it is not all bad and I can't give it lower than a 4. But I'm still not sure exactly what score I'd give it in a review.
|
Cursed
12-15-2002 11:19 AM MST | Rating: 0 | |
WE SHOULD KILL THE REVIEWER('S)
|
[3am]Leto
12-13-2002 08:03 PM MST | Rating: 4 | |
dunno what some people love on the map, but i went crazy (sound and grfx).
One of the classics tho, suddenly commented again :)
|
Smeerkat
04-24-2003 09:39 PM MDT | Rating: 1 | |
So this map gets a 10, and a quality map like DM-Alzamon gets a 6. Congratulations, team, your joke is really funny.
Let's see, 9200 downloads x 2 MB = ....
|
Agent X
12-17-2002 10:08 AM MST | Rating: 0 | |
well what's there to say, there's more obsticles to bump into than opponents, unless your playing with 200 people... LOL Portals, ugly lighting that manages to make Asbestos look good, and just an overall terrible layout...
So this was given a 10 a while back, well the jokes on us, remove the 1 in teh 10 Nali City to bring back truth in advertising. :)
edit : oh yeah, and the music is about the worst piece of garbage ever
|
Hourences
12-14-2002 09:48 AM MST | Rating: 1 | |
1 cause as far as i know it doesnt have flashing green and purple fog everywhere, so thats at least something good
|
|LCN|Vaporizor
12-14-2002 10:55 PM MST | Rating: 6 | |
Not bad, too many objects get in the way of flow. Music gets annoying quickly, although it is a nice change from the normal. Not worth a 10, but it is okay.
|
Ulukai
12-16-2002 06:09 AM MST | Rating: 1 | |
"Not bad"?
Technicolour vomit. But it doesn't crash my PC, so it gets a 1 (just)
|
Shadowlurker
12-15-2002 09:27 AM MST | Rating: 0 | |
no
|
BangOut
12-15-2002 08:45 PM MST | Rating: 0 | |
lol... it was bound to happen sometime
|
blabla
12-18-2002 03:50 AM MST | Rating: 6 | |
What a bunch of children - this map has it's flaws, and I don't enjoy it very much (that stupid hut on stilts is wayyy too hard to get to, and the bots ignore it) and you do get hung up alot of places.
It seems to be an exercise in creative brush work. Or, a robotussin trip. Also the techno track sux0rs. But seriously, a 0? Grow up.
|
Aggressor
12-16-2002 02:56 AM MST | Rating: 5 | |
I have to say that I kind of like this map. Sure, it's cramped as hell in places, it has loads of unused areas, and the architecture is not something to gape upon, but hey I like the hues, I like somewhat out-of-order weapon placement, I like the fragfest and I like the atmosphere. And don't complain about lighting having no apparent sources; this is a magic temple... :P
|
Bot40
12-17-2002 06:14 PM MST | Rating: 1 | |
Total trash, 1/10 for comedy value
oh wait... I thought the comment thing was for rating the review. Let me now rate the map:
Total trash, 1/10 for comedy value
---------------------------
this map shouldnt be a 10, but less than 4 is just ridiculus. ur saying its one of the worst maps in existance, when its mediocare at lowest.
---------------------------
No, this map is total cr4p. Anyone who can't see that is blind. Stupid layout which is way too tight. 0 architecture. Horrible textures, and the lighting is either zone lighting, or greenings.
|
Adam
12-16-2002 03:44 PM MST | Rating: 6 | |
this map shouldnt be a 10, but less than 4 is just ridiculus. ur saying its one of the worst maps in existance, when its mediocare at lowest.
|
[IMD1]KillRoy
12-17-2002 09:40 AM MST | Rating: 4 | |
OMFG, that music!!! :o
|
Trynant
12-17-2002 08:22 PM MST | Rating: 5 | |
not as bad as u would think, some maps are way worse than this for Scimitar to be a zero. Hey it was stunning for it's time.... that's about it.
|
Satyrkarma
12-28-2002 02:38 AM MST | Rating: 6 | |
Reveiw by SATYRKARMA
Design: 8/10
>>>This arena is very intricate. I'm not exactly sure what this place is supposed to represent or why anyone would even build a build like this, but it does make for some interesting gameplay. It seems to me as if the author intended to try everything while building it.
Awe: 6/10
>>>Intricate work. But nothing fancy to me.
Difficulty: 4/10
>>>I found it rather average. I had no problems wasting bots. Not that hard.
Overall: 6/10
>>>Good map but not great. The music is good but I think it clashes with the environment unless someone tells me a really good story to back this one up.
|
DarkHydra
02-11-2003 01:43 PM MST | Rating: 4 | |
When I Installed this map (probably more than a year ago), i wondered why on earth they gave this a 10, and I uninstalled it. Now I know...
|
Cdr_AKiller
02-12-2003 05:51 AM MST | Rating: 10 | |
THIS IS ONE ROCKIN (despite the music) MAP!
TRY IT ON TeamDM!
NUFF SAID...
|
[morpheus]
02-12-2003 09:41 AM MST | Rating: 7 | |
Is this map supposed to be something special? It has quite some original touches alright but I'm not all like "wow-I can't breathe" and all that.
|
Claw
02-12-2003 06:30 PM MST | Rating: 2 | |
Let's keep this alive, shall we?
|
frozenflame
02-12-2003 10:47 PM MST | Rating: 2 | |
Yeah whatever
|
Czm21x
02-13-2003 04:42 PM MST | Rating: 3 | |
When this map first was released I really enjoyed it probably becasue it was new at that time,but now I just don't like this map at all.
Bots: Go most places and pickup most items.
Lights: There are white lights on the walls and yet the rooms are still that hideous blue-green color. These disco maps just don't impress me anymore.
Architexture: Good
Layout: It just kind of goes here and there. Flow suffers because you can't easily get from one spot to another.
Camping spots: That hut on stilts. Good place to camp if you are playing Lms against bots.
It seems that there are only certain map layouts that work well in any first person shooter.
Just look at all the crap that's already been released for UT2003.
|
ReconScout
02-14-2003 05:32 AM MST | Rating: 4 | |
Quite Literally Mediocre, even on TeamDM.
|
GigaVolt
02-15-2003 05:55 PM MST | Rating: 6 | |
Well it's not worth a 10, and the music wasn't that great, it's a pretty cool level, but I was expecting more from the rating. Psychologically the rating given by reviewers made it less appealing. It's an excellent level and I'm having fun playing it, but no way on the 10-ay.
|
ShadoW SnipeR
04-21-2003 10:03 AM MDT | Rating: 0 | |
FUN: Not at all
BORING: As hell
Rating -10 (but i cant do that)
|
Hellscrag2002
04-21-2003 04:51 PM MDT | Rating: 5 | |
I think that anybody who bumps this discussion should get their wrists heartily slapped.
Damn - *slaps wrists*
|
Razor
11-21-2003 05:32 AM MST | Rating: 2 | |
This Map look SOOOOOOOO Ugly and its not fun at ALLLLL
The Best Suckage Ive seen in a long time.....
|
Stakhanov
04-25-2003 12:36 PM MDT | Rating: 1 | |
This map is schlüpeurk.
|
Fodder McFly
04-25-2003 02:33 PM MDT | Rating: 1 | |
The music made me throw my speakers out the window. The odd coloring made me throw up and toss my monitor out the window. I figure that this map owes me about $800. No cash accepted, checks only. ;)
|
The_Real_Meneer_Aard
05-01-2003 02:17 PM MDT | Rating: 6 | |
man i did never new reviewers smoke joints before reviewin...
Talking about joints: the lighting in this map is obiviously build by someone who's high. if thats goo, well... too much colors and too much of the same texture in one map(?)
Game (instagib) was fun, music sux a litlle. you can download it but... well.. if u have nothing else to do(...)
|
AMmayhem
05-09-2003 09:53 PM MDT | Rating: 1 | |
Bad layout, ugly architecture, texturing, & lighting. All around horrible. The only good thing is that you can still kill things...
|
SealClubber
08-18-2003 06:02 PM MDT | Rating: 6 | |
ahh yes, one of the only 10's in the history of nali city!
THIS MAP IS NOT A 10!
:)
|
~shadow~
05-17-2003 02:14 PM MDT | Rating: 0 | |
B!
Not fun!
Strange and............ why 10????????????????????????????????????????
Why?
|
minionofdestruction
05-19-2003 09:38 PM MDT | Rating: 8 | |
WHATS GOOD:
- Fun factor
- Colored highlights from the lights
- Item placement
- Challenge
WHATS BAD:
- Architecture (kinda basic sometimes)
- At many points the map's lights seem to be unified, and not in a good way. It gives that hallway and some of the rest of the map a monotonous feel (correct usage of that word?).
SUMMARY: Very fun map, but not quite a 10.
|
Fuzzy Logic
05-20-2003 09:40 AM MDT | Rating: 10 | |
Best map ever made ;)
|
WoD|_BloodRayne
06-04-2003 04:59 PM MDT | Rating: 10 | |
Best Map Ever. Period. (You people with the 0 ratings obsiously know nothing about maps and what makes them great.)
|
Stalin
06-18-2003 10:06 AM MDT | Rating: 4 | |
eugh... vibrant blue and ancient mario tune... aaaaaaarg!!! This map has no theme. And it gives away a splitting head-ache if you play it for more than 5 seconds. Do not download... unless you're one of these wierdo's who like pain...
|
PlaysWithSelf
07-09-2003 03:32 PM MDT | Rating: 4 | |
Why was my comment removed? becuz i made a sarcastic comment about how this map was rated?
i hate censorship
|
Shao
07-10-2003 09:46 PM MDT | Rating: 0 | |
Rating of this maps:
-To Boring
-To Sucks
-Not fun at all
-I am gonna kill the reviewer
-stop put a 10.
-PLAY IT BEFORE YOU COMMENT!
-bad layouts
-0( nothing special!)
overall:0!
and tks do not put a 10 if you haven't play it!same to the reviewer!
|
Icewind82
07-10-2003 10:32 PM MDT | Rating: 3 | |
this map may look cool, but it has loads of problems. it has a HORRIBLE layout. weapon placement is bad. the official review is WAY overrated
|
SirTahngarth
08-18-2003 10:56 AM MDT | Rating: 0 | |
in case any of you couldnt tell, the review is a purposely sarcastic joke.
|
darkjaxx
10-17-2003 06:20 AM MDT | Rating: 0 | |
Crash.... :/
this review is not serious, why do you become reviewer man? If you don't rate normal. You don't look to the textures (ugly..) You don't look to the architecture(*****( worse) You don't look to the flow, ligthning
I think I never play it again. I'm going to the hospital now, bye!
.........
|
Juno
11-01-2003 10:29 AM MST | Rating: 0 | |
Well it would deserve a 10, but only if the flow would be like DM-Seraphim, the detail like DM-Edge, and it would be so impressive as CTF-HallofGiants...But as it's none of that i'm afraid I'm gonna have to delete it...
P.S. Unfortunately, during the map, my computer caught fire and melted, so I should thank DM-Scimitar
4 my new comp...but I won't.
|
XepptizZ
06-21-2004 03:45 PM MDT | Rating: 0 | |
Reviewer:Unknown???....ofcourse!!! If I knew who he was I'd kick his ass, man what a loser, no afence, or something like that.
Okay, back to the map. Lightning is C-rap the pillars passages and supportbeams are good at some places and beyond ugly in others.
The song really fitts the level:...hardly sane.
And all together it mutilizez UT far beyond recognition.
|
neoduck
11-02-2003 06:28 AM MST | Rating: 0 | |
scimitar pwns me
|
]LoRE[
02-24-2004 05:35 AM MST | Rating: 0 | |
Boo!
|
Sikness220
03-13-2004 10:10 PM MST | Rating: 3 | |
If your trying to be funny im not laughing....
|
CromlecH
03-16-2004 01:15 AM MST | Rating: 2 | |
I had to check this one out, coz of all the commotion written bout it... and,,,
omg.. the music was drivin me nuts.. add to that the colors of this map... i am now typing this in a padded cell, waiting for a lobotomy surgery.. cheers :/
Crap map
|
hype
03-16-2004 06:17 AM MST | Rating: 5 | |
I'm glad it's not just me then . I downloaded this about a year ago because of the high rating and was disappointed to say the least. Whilst it's not a particularly bad map it certainly aint anything special.
|
KosaPL
03-16-2004 08:41 AM MST | Rating: 0 | |
SUcky reviewer
|
FraGnBraG
03-16-2004 05:20 PM MST | Rating: 4 | |
imo, this was never worth a 10, but certainly does NOT deserve a pure ZERO - c'mon u mappers, look closer: there was a bit of imagination applied here - that's gotta count for something (+1) there's differing stuff in it, lots (+1) it had good FR on-line (+1). By the collective reckonings here (if this map really *deserves* a ZERO) most ut maps published prior to fall 2000 really deserve ZERO or negative number ratings :P As a UT-noob back then I remember some crazy on-line matches on packed servers playing in THIS map, and nobody cared too damn much about the colors or lighting - just the fragging (+1) i'll toss in an un-pure 4 because a pure ZERO is just not fair... cheers
|
Nahand
03-17-2004 06:57 AM MST | Rating: 2 | |
... is this still on? Damn...
|
Ironblayde
04-15-2004 04:49 PM MDT | Rating: 9 | |
Nearly perfect, but it loses a point because the author made a stupid oversight when it came to the lighting. The lighting is great, mind you, but it would be even better if the lights used the type LT_TexturePaletteLoop with a skin loaded with as many conflicting colors as possible.
|
Manticore
04-17-2004 02:33 AM MDT | Rating: 3 | |
I agree with a reviewer: you have to see it for yourself. Bizarre architectural construction and lighting. All your little bots run around fine. An interesting texture or two...
For instagib it is actually a fun space but...
|
DannyMeister
04-16-2004 05:08 AM MDT | Rating: 3 | |
Could this become one of the most commented maps ever?
It will be if people don't quit posting comments when there is nothing relevant left to say about the map.
Oops, sorry for posting another irrelevant comment. I didn't even download it :)
|
Mister_Cope
04-17-2004 03:19 PM MDT | Rating: 3 | |
There is no Scimitar, it's an urban legend to scare the children.
let go, and move on.
|
[[TDW-KkillgasmM]]]
06-21-2004 09:35 AM MDT | Rating: 0 | |
eeeeuuuuuuuuuuuuuurrrrrrrghhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh
|
cybersirius
06-21-2004 05:57 PM MDT | Rating: 4 | |
Pros: Architecture is not bad :)
Cons:Lightning is... *vomiting* and item placement is strange.
So,my score is 4.
|
Chrysaor
06-21-2004 08:16 PM MDT | Rating: 10 | |
You know.
|
CursedSoul1
06-22-2004 08:52 AM MDT | Rating: 10 | |
You know,
this map is worlds biggest joke,
its fugly, its sad, its depressing, and the mapper probably sliced his own wrists while hanging out of the window with a rope around his neck,
and thats the fun of this map,
it doesnt have any play value (unless your a drunk, high, stoned person that doesnt understand reality.
the map itself deserves a big phat whopping '0'
but i have known this map for ages and still people comment on this crappy map, and there are still people that fall for it, and there are still people getting angry about other people giving this map a 10.
its a damn classic, and though the playability sucks,
the fun i have had reading this comments, and realising that this is going on for years made me give this map a 10.
just for the fun of it.
|
Frieza
06-22-2004 01:46 PM MDT | |
God, that people still comment on this piece of junk.
|
The Brazilian Novice
06-22-2004 04:47 PM MDT | |
Unknown reviwer uh?!
|
nightshadow
06-23-2004 12:33 PM MDT | Rating: 1 | |
i didn't like this map at all. it was nothing special and doesn't make my play list.
|
VindicatorEX
07-05-2004 01:50 AM MDT | Rating: 1 | |
wat map is this?
|
Jez
11-21-2004 03:35 PM MST | Rating: 0.5 | |
A crap one!
|
RayZidane
11-21-2004 08:04 PM MST | Rating: 0 | |
come on!
|
Sergeant Todd
11-22-2004 12:04 AM MST | Rating: 3 | |
This oldie has been overtaken by time. After playing maps from Smeerkat, Paranoid, Chthon and other excellent mappers, DM-Scimitar now shows its age. It does NOT deserve a zero, however. Sorry, Caylo.
|
Evil Snack
04-21-2005 05:36 PM MDT | Rating: 0 | |
Well....It's bad. If you wanted to know what bad times bad to the 5000th power is, You will get a map like this.
Hmmm....Anybody know of some especially bad maps that I could make a story about? (Other than this).
|
redfist
11-22-2004 02:14 PM MST | Rating: 2.5 | |
17,000 downloads,hmm
I will say it is not all very good,however,it's not a box map,he did make a music file.
Gameplay is not good,and I think if the map was lit better people wouldn't think it was as bad as they think.
These sourcastic 10 scores and zero posting shows the mentality of the commenter.map is about a 2.5 or 3 max.
|
SamAeL
01-04-2005 07:04 PM MST | Rating: 2.5 | |
is this a joke ?
|
Deceased
04-22-2005 11:25 AM MDT | Rating: 1 | |
i reckon this is someones little joke. review it high, only let a few people in on it and make it out to be the "best map ever" and annoy everyone.
c'mon guys, this is old crap now... move on to slating the newer map :P
|
{SpY}Infallible
05-07-2006 03:21 PM MDT | Rating: 0 | |
DavidM or Hourences lighting? hmm...tough one.
Ulukai or Caylo architecture? ULUKAI!
all i can say about this rating is:
HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH OMFG!!!! ROFLMFAO!!!! BHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAGHAAAAAAA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
EDIT:I gave a 0 to compensate for the review score ds, =P
|
Charon
05-02-2006 08:35 PM MDT | Rating: 2 | |
Lol, I've almost forgot about it;)
|
Mister_Prophet
05-03-2006 04:55 PM MDT | |
The dead horse has decomposed long ago.
|
cccdeathstorm
05-05-2006 03:36 PM MDT | Rating: 10 | |
first off all ain't worth a 10 no, i'm giving it a 10 to compensate the other's ass 0 score, bet they didn't even download it.
the map is well, not detailed built and the texture choise is hmm horrible
but, i like the lighting, the fun factor = HIGH
bots "sorta" tried to shoot me, i like the tune, adds a bit of hyperactive feeling to it.
anyway, you should all be ashamed rating this thing "0"
my rating 5.5
|
Leo
05-06-2006 09:21 AM MDT | Rating: 0.5 | |
Overall this map is quite a considerable abomination. The lighting, while quite hideous, resembles that of some junky on an acid trip. The texturing is far too bland, and the level architecture is, well, repulsive. I give this map a 0.5 simply because it worked. This truely is not worthy of any bandwidth usage or hard-disk space.
|
iced_scream
05-06-2006 11:15 AM MDT | Rating: 3 | |
Outside of a little bit of decent architechture in places, this level is pretty bad. Gets a 3 from me mainly because it works and includes a custom music track.
The biggest problem is that it's just so gaudy and garish with the "gay disco lighting" and bizarre texture choices.
I know this is a joke review, but maybe it's time to find another map to rip on? ;)
|
Corey(:K256:)
05-07-2006 05:05 AM MDT | Rating: 5 | |
with all this weird comments I just had to check this map out. And I must say it isn't at all that but. I totally agree that a 10 is way too high. But a 0 is too low at the bottom.
|
LiquidSteel
05-07-2006 10:41 AM MDT | Rating: 6.5 | |
Not a 10, and certainly not a 0 by any means.
|
Rakiayn
05-08-2006 08:57 AM MDT | Rating: 3 | |
a 3 will do
|
UT
UT2k3
U2
UT2k4 
