| Shambler | Rating: 9 | |
This map is very 1337, one of DavidM's genuinely good maps along with Pahgio. 7 for Architecture?? Pah, have you see that outside bit by Rifle?? Fucking superb... I think you're missing the point Twrecks, this is not supposed to be a realistic prison that Real Maps would review and would work with Inf., it's supposed to be a very playable UT map with prison elements to give it a strong theme and good details.
|
| Kain | Rating: 7 | |
your score's spot on Twrecks, this map is nice to look at in places but can't decide whether it is a gimmick/realistic map or a hardcore map. As a result it plays like a small room-corridor map with some cool details but no cool gameplay.
|
| Frostblood | Rating: 6.5 | |
Traps are great, and it looks nice, but the gameplays nothing we havent seen before. Good gimmick map but not really a keeper
|
| -=ViperJP=- | Rating: 8 | |
One of David's finest maps. I like alcatraz.
|
| Shock6822 | Rating: 8.5 | |
It does look cheesy in places, but runs fine, and plays great
|
| Metago | Rating: 8.5 | |
I have now gained a little respect for DavidM's mapping ability
|
| David 'DAVIDM' Münnich | |
wow, I found a review worse than the agio and the pah one :D
|
| HypErioN | Rating: 8 | |
Twrecks? What are you? The president of all the worlds Retards? :D Its not the score that im pissed at, its the review! "Mine"...? "Mine"?!?!? There's no farking mine textures in this map! It uses Akuma's l33t oilrig textures... not Mine! Oh, and you cant review with such a system... No map is fun with framerates below 15, and i bet no map runs more than 15 fps on your rig... I mean, i can barely get above 20 fps on my old K6-2 400mhz/Voodoo2 system :P
|
| Twrecks | Rating: 7.5 | |
I probably should have worded that "the custom UTX is like...". I'll give you the 0.5pts Hyp :p
|
| ]BMR[VorLoN | Rating: 10 | |
ONLY 7.5??? Hey the map looks great, plays great and is one of David`s best DM maps, along with Pahgio and Pah! PS: realism SUCKS!!! If you can biuld the map better than David, the 7.5 is ok.(but I think you can`t because it`s PERFECT) Keep on mapping David, waiting for your next map!
|
| sprag | Rating: 8 | |
This is one fine map. Play flow is hard and fast and I like playing this map with 5 or 6 bots jacked up to adept and all carrying tac op weapons. Great job!
|
| Dai | Rating: 6 | |
it looks nice and all - and the skybox is great. But the layout is flat and the traps are kind of boring. the textures are great tho, but that's Akumas doing, not Davids.
|
| Olav 'MrFawn' Gjerde | Rating: 7 | |
Dai, Its about how u use the textures. Im gonna use them for my TO map ------------------------- Layout is shit. A bit slow Good atmosphere Architecture is very good, lightning too
|
| Claymore | Rating: 8 | |
I like it, but I tend to judge most maps on how they look, not on how they play. :
|
| Blooddog_sweden | Rating: 9 | |
Everyone of DavidM:s maps are getting bad scores. This is a very good map.The lightning is not a seven it's a 10.The gameplay can be better but it's allready great. You are the man David!!!!
|
| garrett | Rating: 8 | |
i like
|
| Krofinzki | Rating: 10 | |
What are you talking about Twrecks?!??! This map plainly rocks! it has great arcitecture/design/playability and the Superb Textures! made by Rich 'Akuma' Eastwood! and man you need to get a new computer! UT maps do look ugly on a 233 (i know i still have one)
|
| shad0h | Rating: 7.5 | |
Should I try to run this on my P200 MMX, 64Meg, 8Meg ATI and see how it goes? I bet it's even MORE fun to play then. Nahhh, my PII machine is LOW end, my old pc is NO end. The old machine did run UNREAL 1 ok though.
|
| Scourge | Rating: 9 | |
Compare this to, say, DM-Helleth and tell me why it shouldn't have at least 9. Nice, if not perfect flow, good visuals, good theme. And it runs 25+ fps on my K6-2 300 with Voodoo II. Definitely one of the best maps out there.
|
| FlakHarvester | Rating: 7 | |
its one of M's best but that ain't hard. I don't get why people are loving this level so much, it is hardly brilliant. Twrecks on this rare occasion got it right, not that good!
|
| Red Fox | Rating: 9.5 | |
This map is Brilliant!!!Hello from Russia and Happy New Year!
|
| Bones1198 | Rating: 10 | |
He must have done something right...it OWNZ !!!
|
| Agent X | Rating: 7 | |
My second fav David M map for visuals. Gameplay is ok for run and gun. 7.5 by the reviewer, pretty spot on.
|
| Ramdole Kang | Rating: 8.5 | |
I love this map! It's got that oldskool unreal1 feeling to it. Definitely one of David's best maps
|
| Ammo | Rating: 3 | |
a waste of time
|
| Nemesis | Rating: 9 | |
This map is up to the usual standard for DavidM. It flows, great textures, lighting and tough bots. What is your problem, Kain, with DavidM? You bitch about every one of his maps as though they are shit, which they are not. As a Nali City reviewer, you are shooting your credibility to bits, dude. Get some ideas on how to conduct a balanced review by going and reading CliffyB's Ownage site. Just so happens that three of DavidM's maps are there, including two you reviewed. I tend to think that CliffyB knows a little bit more about mapping than you, pal. STFU and review. Nali City and QAPete deserve better from you.
|
| kyuzo | Rating: 8.5 | |
This map's hot! Grab it now!.......I sure hope some servers start running it...And hey reviewer - ease up with the scoring a little eh?
|
| Akuma | Rating: 8 | |
I normally don't like semi-'realistic' maps much, but do like this level :) No way anyone could accurately recreate something like Alcatraz unless they spent a week there with a camera & sketch-pad.
|
| Deathwing | Rating: 8 | |
Lag is the only thing bringing this map down.
|
| Joeman | Rating: 9.5 | |
PAH! What were you thinking! This map kicks A$$!!!!! I wouldn't go so far as to say it's 'perfect' but it's damn near close! BLAA! I say! BLAA!
|
| SirFraggedalot | Rating: 8 | |
Not sold on the layout, but when CliffyB gives it Ownage, and Akuma gives an 8 for user feedback, its gotta be good since they really know about mapping. Richrig texture set owns!
|
| xanyashi | Rating: 8.5 | |
I don't see why this map got such a low score (especially compared to some of the garbage that has gotten much higher scores on this site) ... the layout wasn't too bad (i think pahgio is more fun tho) and the visuals are pretty kick ass.
|
| Ulukai | Rating: 8.5 | |
Impressive.
|
| Requiem | Rating: 9 | |
Maps should be first af all qualified by their gameplay! And this one... ROCKS! The Connectivity is excellent! (Did you ever think how fun can be running away from someone for two minutes because of being out of ammo, catching health packs and armors on your way, jumping over tables, on/from stairs...) An awesome map!
|
| Master Tonnberry | Rating: 9 | |
that's ass-kicking stuff!
|
| =G3nocid3= | Rating: 9 | |
His best map so far. I only don't like the gaschamber.
|
| Zathlar | Rating: 0 | |
Well this sounds like a cool map, but since the latest drivers were installed on my computer, something has screwed up my UT. Something to do with sound or another. So my score is N/A at this time and not a 0....but, like in those famous words: I'll be back...and give a score.
|
| U2_RicAxl | Rating: 9 | |
I think you made a great map. U2
|
| Tom Browett | Rating: 8.5 | |
the score of 7.5 might be ok, if you hadnt given the same mark to that peice of crap DM-Bedroom thing
|
| Zed_Blacksword | Rating: 8 | |
Everybody just have to play this fun little map! It's got another feeeeeeling than the other ones.(remember, feeling is good) A great map!
|
| UT_Centurion | Rating: 8 | |
Good map. I like Richrig.utx, but all things aside, this is a mediocre map on the scale of DavidM achievement. You people are too obsessed with David's '1337ness' >=(
|
| Mike3894 | Rating: 8 | |
.....
|
| Lophead | Rating: 7 | |
I find the DavidM's gimmicky approach to this level would work great in a UT single player map. (perhaps something for the future?) You get that real immersive sense of actually being somewhere, kind of like in halflife.
|
| BloodyL | Rating: 7 | |
I found DM-Alcatraz quite a dissapointment, it's nowhere near DavidM's standard at all. If you take the DavidM's name away from it, the map would be just the same as every other 7 scored map made by joe schmoe. Try again DavidM.....
|
| ryanbrucks | Rating: 9 | |
Nice map. Pretty good looking, slightly more colorful lighting might have been nicer though.
|
| cosmonaut | Rating: 0 | |
Sucks Arse
|
| Al ZheimeR | Rating: 0 | |
This map sucks so much that i formatted my hd after playing it .
|
| canadian-lizard | Rating: 8.5 | |
Brill! This is a great level but may need some layout work and weapons in corners not in the thick of it but otherwise...I love it! P.s: I'll probably get some flack either way!
|
| Hortons Who | Rating: 6 | |
looks nice, plays OK... nothing new really and it got old after a few frags.
|
| Fordy | Rating: 7 | |
Umm im not really posting feedback on the map, more commenting on Nali City, Why so few reviews when you have so many map sent in ? By the way, I think DM-alcatraz should now be map of the year since its beem MOTW for so bloody long.
|
| Lustmord | Rating: 6.5 | |
Is anybody actually reading this far down?
|
| Scorpio_911 | Rating: 7 | |
NEXT!
|
| [OMC]Xylander | Rating: 2 | |
by the way nemesis:I agree that his score is unfair, this shit is worth even LOWER
|
| Gladiator | Rating: 7 | |
It runs on my PII 300mhz, 64 MB Ram and a Tridnet Ciber. -yeehaw-
|
| FluXs | Rating: 5 | |
[url]http://nalicity.beyondunreal.com/reviewpics/dm-seraphim2.jpg[/url] ;(
|
Shao
08-06-2003 02:40 PM MDT | Rating: 9 | |
goody guty!
|
Nahand
08-07-2003 06:14 AM MDT | Rating: 5 | |
... i tried... a long time ago... but i just CAN´T like it... god knows i tried...
|
fishdonuts
08-24-2003 10:25 AM MDT | Rating: 8 | |
Did this come before or after the Jailbreak version JB-Alcatraz (it came with JB3 Gold)?
|
Mxtrmntr
08-24-2003 05:02 PM MDT | Rating: 7 | |
fishdonuts: way before.
Not bad, but not up to the usual DavidM standard concerning the gameplay ;)
|
darkjaxx
12-07-2003 03:38 PM MST | Rating: 8 | |
Wow i like the goodies!
But gameplay is almost good
sometimes you can not good trough the doors, and an bot shoots your dead
But this I want see more!:D
GoowD Job!
How you can say that architectural it looks bad?
hum, i don't think so ;)
|
MexicanFlava
08-30-2003 11:03 PM MDT | Rating: 8 | |
Typical DavidM map. Brownish look, not that that's bad, and great gameplay. I really liked how the sunset was done. It was really fun with the WeaponLord mod on. Hell, everything is fun with the WeaponLord mod on.
|
PeDi
12-06-2003 03:29 PM MST | Rating: 8 | |
...Nice one!
|
Jez
01-23-2004 05:38 PM MST | Rating: 7 | |
DavidM makes great maps. Unfortunately this isn't one of his best. I suggest anyone who thinks this is his best work should try some of his other maps, such as DM-Roon with lots of z-axis and great flow. Alcatraz pales in comparison. This doesn't deserve a 10 by any standards.
|
Uncle_Bob
04-18-2004 04:42 AM MDT | Rating: 7 | |
I like the Alcatraz theme and especialy the electric chair trap. Its a good flowing DM map, but I think you could tell the sky box was a cube which slightly spoiled it. Apart from that its a fine map!
|
Commander2
08-13-2005 02:28 PM MDT | Rating: 9 | |
Wish I could go farther into the sea :D
Wonderful map, seriously.
|
Sir Xavius
08-17-2005 12:23 PM MDT | Rating: 8 | |
Loved it! There are tight areas, there are open areas...the only thing missing are the secret chambers. Whether you're a camper or a fragger, you'll enjoy this map.
|
HeadshotChampion
08-17-2005 01:13 PM MDT | Rating: 2 | |
ICH collision hull in the sky like an additional floor, you can walk the entire front of the level this way. Better testplay your maps next time. Apart from that a boring texture theme map. The "1337" LCD is not even animated. WHo do you think likes stuff like that?
Geometry is good tho, but I know you can do way better stuff (thinking of what you did in Operation Na Pali)
|
Rakiayn
08-17-2005 02:27 PM MDT | Rating: 8 | |
nice map looks very good
|
UT
UT2k3
U2
UT2k4 
