_Reciprocity
10-30-2004 11:58 PM MDT | |
Wasn't a Phobos port shot down a while ago?
|
redfist
10-31-2004 01:07 AM MDT | |
Yep,never tried it,i might try them and see wich is better/
|
slaskan
10-31-2004 08:12 AM MST | |
what?.. not again pleees
|
CursedSoul1
11-01-2004 03:07 PM MST | |
some people never learn.. :(
edit: still a copy.
be original, youll be respected for it.
|
[SvL]Zalmoxis
10-31-2004 01:57 PM MST | |
Its an updated version. If you do not have any actual comments, please do not reply.
It is NOT a port. I constructed the level from scratch.
|
Slainchild
10-31-2004 05:36 PM MST | |
Quote: It is NOT a port. I constructed the level from scratch.
Unfortunately, some people here don't realise how hard that is.
EDIT: It seems you have not included the file called DoorsMod, so the map is only playable through the editor.
|
ChromeBallz
11-01-2004 11:25 PM MST | |
It doesn't matter how hard it is to do. Fact is, it's a copy.
Copies are bad.
[edit]
It's not about remakes.
It's about BAD remakes and plain copies.
I like to see a good remake, such as EternalCavesClassic or Coret-Classic. There's also a very good deck remake, though i don't remember the exact name.... And Morpheus2 and Curse4 as prime examples. THOSE are good remakes of old maps. Curse is even from the original Unreal.
What i DON'T like are copies and remakes made on the principle of "extract a few cubes and call it version 2". For that i just play the original game.
|
Ripperjack
11-01-2004 10:49 AM MST | |
I love the classics since without the classics there would be no Unreal or UT. There are a lot (I would even venture to say over half) of the UT community that love 'remakes', me included. As long as it's made from scratch, on a new engine build, the flair of the new author is achieved and proper credit given where applicable (original creator, textures, meshes), I see no reason to treat it and score it like a new map. Obviously getting a medium to low score on originality but that's really not one of the big reason for scoring a map IMHO since there really aren't any 'really' original maps since UT and Quake III. Pretty much anything 'original' has been done.
Sorry for the rant. Just getting tired of the 'remake' wreckers out there. I myself don't play much DM but was drawn here with the nostalgia of the UT version of Phobos. I obviously like a lot of the classics and look forward to other mappers versions and how they would tweak it (anyone want to make a 'remake' of Unearthed that puts the flak back in the water? Heh). So I haven't played this map and sorry I don't have a comment about it specifically. Look for an edit where I give my take soon.
|
Ma!ice
11-04-2004 05:20 PM MST | Rating: 0 | |
Do your Own thing...sheesh
|
sandorski
11-07-2004 08:16 PM MST | Rating: 6.5 | |
A good remake of a classic map. The only complaint I have is that being outside made me dizzy.
|
UT
UT2k3
U2
UT2k4 
